... VL - 20. Learn more from patient advocates from across the industry. MedStar Institute for Innovation New safety report: 15 years after “To Err is Human” The National Patient Safety Foundation (NPSF) recently released a report, titled “Free from Harm: Accelerating Patient Safety Improvement Fifteen Years after To Err is Human,” which discusses and evaluates the status of patient safety 15 years after the release of To Err is Human. A noted researcher re-examines how far we’ve come since then and the difficult cooperation it will take to make patient safety more certain. Published November 20, 2019. Supporting the healthcare workforce Methodist Hospital of Southern California 11/18/2019. Twenty years ago, a comprehensive report was published that called to the forefront of the healthcare industry the need to reduce medical errors. Optimizing health IT for patient safety In…, eMagazine Top 9 Apps of 2018 As the healthcare industry changes, the need for smarter technologies increases. A New Era for Reducing Injurious Falls and Healthy Aging. MktoForms2.loadForm("//app-sj21.marketo.com", "267-SDD-453", 1543); ©2020 Allscripts Healthcare, LLC and/or its affiliates. And in that time, the healthcare industry has seen vast changes, bringing patient … “Everyone sat up and said: ‘Wow, we’re not very good. For surgeons, quality issues that still demand attention include wrong-site surgery and the continued incidence of unintended retained foreign objects (URFOs). UH Patient Family Partnership Council AU - Sexton, Bryan. “We cannot continue to use the same methods and expect different results,” Dr. Chassin wrote. By implementing strategies such as optimizing health IT usability, advocating on behalf of patients and supporting healthcare workers, patient safety continues trending upward—leading to better outcomes. Feds on the front lines Soon after the release of To Err Is Human , Congress passed legislation requiring the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) to issue annual reports designed to monitor progress in improving care. The Allscripts Developer Program builds a culture of innovation by reducing barriers and risk associated with installing and using innovative. National Vital Statistics Reports. What has all of this got to do with the treatment of conditions such as diabetes? Continued progress with patient safety will follow a strong commitment to make it part of our organizational culture. My personal take on the IOM report is positive. The report marked a pivotal moment in the health care industry, policymaking, and society’s expectations about how health care is provided. Here’s are some of the advances that have come to define the modern patient safety movement over the past 20 years — and where we still need to go. ... Chassin M, Foster N. Patient safety leader reflects on ‘To Err is Human’ report. MedStar Health Research Institute A total of 104 incidents of wrong-patient, wrong-site, wrong-procedure events were reported in 2017, with another 98 reported in 2018. The push for patient safety that followed its release continues. 2388 JAMA, May 18, 2005—Vol 293, No. Two decades later, Mark R. Chassin, MD, FACP, MPP, MPH, president and chief executive officer of The Joint Commission—a member of the IOM Committee on Quality of Health Care in America that wrote the To Err Is Humanreport—believes that although that report and others have led to improvements in the health care system, the rates of familiar quality issues remain too high. Reducing medical errors comes from a steadfast commitment to patient safety, enhanced by the right technology tools. 20 Years After “To Err is Human”, Leapfrog Hospital Safety Grades Prove Transparency Can Save Lives. The report highlighted the incidence of medical errors and preventable deaths in the United States and catalyzed research to identify interventions for improvement. In this US based eMagazine Patient Safety: 20 Years after ‘To Err is Human,’ sees thought leaders from across the healthcare industry examine how shifting to patient-centred care has helped organisations across the country sustain a deeper culture of patient safety. They are as follows:3. World Health Organization, In this issue, we celebrate top healthcare apps from our partner developers this past year. But Hospitals Are Still Struggling. Breadcrumb. Deaths: Final data for 1997. Book/Report. 2005 May 18;293(19):2384-2390. Being a patient advocate means collaborating with everyone to drive patient safety, which includes nurturing patient engagement. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (National Center for Health Statistics). vention have joined with more than 20. surgical organizations in a new pro-gram to reduce surgical complica- ... FIVE YEARS AFTER TO ERR IS HUMAN. In a recent High Reliability Healthcare blog post, Dr. Chassin reflected on the future impact of To Err Is Human and how health care can continue to improve. Chassin M. To Err is Human: The next 20 years. Institute of Medicine (U.S.) Committee on Quality of Health Care in America, Kohn LT, Corrigan JM, Donaldson MS, eds. In the episode, Dr. Chassin described the impact of the To Err Is Human report on health care safety.4, So where do we go from here? 633 N. Saint Clair St. New processes, new devices, new ways of providing treatment—yes, innovation—continues full throttle, and while these advances have benefited society in a significant way, they also have created vulnerability and risks that were not present before. The report marked a pivotal moment in the health care industry, policymaking, and society’s expectations about how health care is provided. A human factors approach considers how humans interact with technology and seeks to improve HIT usability. 20 Years After “To Err is Human”, Leapfrog Hospital Safety Grades Prove Transparency Can Save Lives. The Institute of Medicine (IOM, now known as the National Academy of Medicine) 20 years ago published the landmark report, To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System. URFOs were the top sentinel event reported to The Joint Commission in 2017 (124 reported) and again in 2018 (121 reported). According to Leape and Berwick (2005) and Wachter (2004), who studied improvements in patient safety five years after To Err is Human, but also according to … Carolyn M. Clancy, MD. Partnering with patients for the safest care I was a member of the Institute of Medicine’s Committee on Quality of Health Care in America, which wrote To Err is Human: Building a Safer Health System in 1999. November marks the 10-year anniversary of the Institute of Medicine's "To Err Is Human." January 6, 2016. Five years after To Err Is Human: What have we learned? Available at: National Vital Statistics Reports. Dr. Chassin touched on the To Err Is Human report and more in a Modern Healthcare editorial, “One-size-fits-all approach to patient safety improvement won’t get us to the ultimate goal—zero harm.” Dr. Chassin laid out three changes health care leadership can make to ensure patients receive higher quality care. The thoughts and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of Dr. Pellegrini and do not necessarily reflect those of The Joint Commission or the American College of Surgeons. Am I satisfied with the rate of harm surgical patients continue to experience? Shortly before the symposium at the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) building in Washington to review progress on patient safety, the not-for-profit National Patient Safety Foundation (NPSF) released its own report calling for heightened efforts to reduce medical harm: "Free from Harm: Accelerating Patient Safety Improvement 15 Years after To Err Is Human." Health Care 20 Years After ‘To Err is Human’ Report . Creating and sustaining a safety culture Full interoperability already exists, and with it comes the capacity to seamlessly share and integrate patient information across care pathways. All rights reserved. With late 2019 marking the 20th anniversary of the landmark report on medical errors “To Err is Human,” now is time for a renewed focus on novel ways to improve patient safety. Two decades later, Mark R. Chassin, MD, FACP, MPP, MPH, president and chief executive officer of The Joint Commission—a member of the IOM Committee on Quality of Health Care in America that wrote the To Err Is Human report—believes that although that report and others have led to improvements in the health care system, the rates of familiar quality issues remain too high. All Allscripts Practice Financial Platform, Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI), Methodist Hospital of Southern California, National Center for Human Factors in Healthcare, Next Now: Activating Community Healthcare, NextNow – Recovering the health of your practice’s revenue cycle, COVID-19: Weathering the crisis, shaping the future of care delivery, How understanding social determinants can deliver community wellness. There have been leaps forward in patient safety over the past 20 years but harm remains far too common, two experts say. Fifteen years after the release of the IOM’s landmark report, To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System, two new reports highlight the progress we’ve made and also argue that we still have far to go to make care as safe as it should be for all patients.IHI Vice President Frank Federico was a member of the expert panel that contributed to a new National Patient Safety Foundation report. ‘To Err Is Human’ Initiative Set A Goal Of Curbing Preventable Medical Errors 20 Years Ago. Summary. The Institute of Medicine (IOM) called for a national effort to make health care safe in its landmark 1999 report, To Err Is Human . Sep 10, 2020 - 12:00 PM - Sep 10, 2020 - 01:00 PM CHESP Summer 2020 Extended Review Session - Chicago, IL. Learn more from safety experts from Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI), American Hospital Association and Methodist Hospital of Southern California. Download the app via the Apple Store, Google Play, or Amazon. By Mark Chassin, MD, FACP, MPP, MPH, president and CEO, The Joint Commission. The report, “To Err is Human,” demonstrated that nearly 2-4% of deaths in the United States were caused by avoidable medical errors. Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI) Well, quite a lot. National patient safety goals include recognizing how medical errors affect those that work in health IT. JO - Journal of Critical Care. We took a novel approach and chronicled this story, reported new data comparing national infection rates from the 1990s with rates in 2013 and provided our insights of what components led to this success. EP - 78. Learn more from ECRI Institute and Allscripts physicians. AU - Pronovost, Peter. To Err is Human: 15 Years Later To mark the anniversary of the Institute of Medicine’s watershed report To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System, West Health is running a series of interviews with IOM committee members who helped produce the report, as well as other national health experts to examine what progress has been made in reducing medical errors in the US. November 13, 2019. Partnership for Health IT Patient Safety American Hospital Association patient safety leader reflects on ‘To Err is Human’ report. If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. In our new eMagazine, “Patient Safety: 20 Years after ‘To Err is Human,’” thought leaders from across the healthcare industry examine how shifting to patient-centered care has helped organizations across the country sustain a deeper culture of patient safety. SP - 76. PY - 2005/3. We explore solutions that meet the current pandemic head-on, discuss how they shape healthcare delivery for good. The report cited a study that estimated at least 44,000 patients die annually in the U.S. as a result of medical errors, with an additional study suggesting it could be as high as 98,000.1 The report also stated that deaths attributed to medical errors exceeded “the number attributable to the eighth-leading cause of death,” which at the time was suicide.1-3 More importantly, the report highlighted the fact that most medical errors were the result of failures of the system rather than specifically attributable to individuals.1. JF - Journal of Critical Care. Managing those risks, creating a culture of safety, and continuing to focus on ways to identify and eliminate threats before they become errors is, in my view, the greatest legacy of this report and a moral imperative for every surgeon. Tagged as: quality improvement, The Joint Commission, To Err Is Human, Bulletin of the American College of Surgeons Learn more from MedStar Institute for Innovation, Northwell Health’s Usability Lab and Allscripts user-centered design team. T1 - Five years after to err is human. To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System is a landmark report issued in November 1999 by the U.S. Institute of Medicine that may have resulted in increased awareness of U.S. medical errors. For surgeons, quality issues that still demand attention include wrong-site surgery and the continued incidence of unintended retained fo… In the Modern Healthcare commentary, Dr. Chassin also wrote that “the method we have employed is the ‘one-size-fits-all’ best practice.”3 But that approach often leads to modest or inconsistent improvements that are difficult to sustain over time. 20 Years After “To Err is Human,” Leapfrog Hospital Safety Grades Prove Transparency Can Save Lives November 7, 2019 The Leapfrog Group’s fall 2019 Hospital Safety Grades , announced today, highlight progress in bringing patient safety into the sunlight and demonstrate improvement from a problem first made prominent in a landmark report released 20 years ago. Journal of the American Medical Association. The Allscripts Developer Program builds, In this issue, community healthcare leaders share their journeys in choosing the right solutions, achieving stronger care outcomes and thriving, In this issue, read about revenue cycle management optimization, which is critical for providers currently recovering from financial losses brought. “Evidence is accumulating that process improvement methods long used successfully in industry—Lean, Six Sigma and change management, taken together—are far more effective than the ‘one-size-fits-all’ best-practice approach.”3, Dr. Chassin also spoke with Nancy Foster, American Hospital Association vice-president for quality and patient safety, for the Advancing Health podcast. However, safety is not a static goal line but rather a moving target. Physician practice managers know that it takes much more than technology to successfully navigate today’s increasing cost pressures. October 5, 1999. This report increased awareness of medical errors in the U.S. and also called for health care system changes that would lead to improvements in patient safety and quality of care. June 30, 1999. That landmark Institute of Medicine (IOM) report found that up to 98,000 Americans die in hospitals every year from preventable medical errors—surpassing deaths from car crashes, breast cancer, and AIDS. Learn about how organizations are driving outcomes with sepsis, medications and precision medicine. I believe that before the report was published, health care leaders were primarily focused on innovation. Ten Years After To Err Is Human. The report, “To Err is Human,” demonstrated that nearly 2-4% of deaths in the United States were caused by avoidable medical errors. Approach to Improving Safety. One area of…, eMagazine Hello, Consumer This issue provides insight into how the healthcare industry is communicating with patients as they take control…. To Err is Human: The Next 20 Years . Northwell Health’s Usability Lab SN - 0883-9441. The Leapfrog Group’s fall 2019 Hospital Safety Grades, announced today, highlight progress in bringing patient safety into the sunlight and demonstrate improvement from a problem first made prominent in a landmark report released 20 years ago. 20 years after 'To Err is Human; hospital care quality measures are still of little use Modern Healthcare discusses the takeaways of the “To Err is Human” report, which has indicated the need for new, more stringent hospital care quality measures. Topics. Births and deaths: Preliminary data for 1998. Chicago, IL 60611, Carlos A. Pellegrini, MD, FACS, FRCSI(Hon), FRCSEng(Hon), FRCSEd(Hon), www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr47/nvs47_19.pdf, www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr47/nvs47_25.pdf, www.modernhealthcare.com/opinion-editorial/one-size-fits-all-approach-patient-safety-improvement-wont-get-us-ultimate-goal, www.aha.org/advancing-health-podcast/2019-11-13-patient-safety-leader-reflects-err-human-report, www.jointcommission.org/resources/news-and-multimedia/blogs/high-reliability-healthcare/2019/11/to-err-is-human-the-next-20-years/, Drastically overhaul the institutional culture, Understand that safety processes often fail at rates of 50 percent or more. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (National Center for Health Statistics). National Center for Human Factors in Healthcare Patient-centered care requires us to take a close look at how we can use technology to improve patient safety. AU - Thompson, David. Of course not. IS - 1. The release of the Institute of Medicine's To Err Is Human in 1999 represented a seminal moment in patient safety and is considered by many to have launched the modern patient safety movement. The publication sparked an evolution in healthcare, one that focused on patient-centered care—and more than anything—better patient safety. WASHINGTON—When it was released 15 years ago, “To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System” created shock waves in the U.S. medical community and in the general public. Available at: Chassin M. One-size-fits-all approach to patient safety improvement won’t get us to the ultimate goal—zero harm. The publication sparked an evolution in healthcare, one that focused on patient-centered care—and more than anything—better patient safety. ... Oct 20, 2020 - 04:30 PM Should Zero Falls Be The Goal? The report, “To Err is Human,” demonstrated that nearly 2-4% of deaths in the United States were caused by avoidable medical errors. “We’ve made some significant progress, but the next major gains will arise only from the efforts of health care leadership and organizations, not government, business, market forces, nor patient advocacy groups,” Dr. Chassin wrote.5, He also asked that after 20 years, “Who is satisfied with the current state?” He noted, “If we’re not satisfied, we need to change the way we have been going about improvement.”5. American Journal of Medical Quality 2009 24: 6, 525-528 Download Citation. To acknowledge the 20 th anniversary of To Err is Human, AJMQ republished and reflected on 11 of their own most downloaded and cited articles from the past 20 years, discussing how each of the articles have directly impacted the safety of health care. The publication sparked an evolution in healthcare, one that focused on patient-centered care—and more than anything—better patient safety. American Hospital Association eMagazine Beyond Usability Health IT has come a long way over the last decade, but is it truly helping? November 26, 2019 - It’s been 20 years since the Institute of Medicine — known now as the National Academy of Medicine — published the groundbreaking report, To Err is Human. Driving meaningful outcomes That movement toward safety has grown ever since, and that, I believe, has provided enormous benefits to our patients.6. The Institute of Medicine report “To Err Is Human” in 1999 shook health care with the finding that as many as 120,000 Americans die each year due to medical mistakes. ECRI Institute Fifteen years after To Err is Human, the reduction in CLABSI is a success story that could inform other harm reduction efforts. In our new eMagazine, “Patient Safety: 20 Years after ‘To Err is Human,’” thought leaders from across the healthcare industry examine how shifting to patient-centered care has helped organizations across the country sustain a deeper culture of patient safety. Starting in early 2000 (the report was released in November 1999), attention rapidly shifted from a focus on innovation as a way to advance health care to a focus on safety. , 2020 - 04:30 PM Should Zero Falls Be the Goal MD, FACP MPP... Urfos ) explore solutions that meet the current pandemic head-on, discuss how they shape healthcare delivery good! 24: 6, 525-528 download citation shape healthcare delivery for good sepsis, and... Innovation by Reducing barriers and risk associated with installing and using 20 years after to err is human our patients.6, one focused... All of this got to do with the treatment of conditions such as diabetes my personal take on IOM... Llc and/or its affiliates Center for Health Statistics ) medical Quality 2009 24: 6, 525-528 download citation re. Wrong-Procedure events were reported in 2018 that movement toward safety has grown ever,... Far too common, two experts say patient advocates from across the industry, FACP MPP! Southern California, enhanced by the right technology tools have we learned for smarter technologies increases that the... Ceo, the need for smarter technologies increases `` //app-sj21.marketo.com '', 1543 ) ; ©2020 healthcare... Industry changes, the need to reduce medical errors and preventable deaths the. Md, FACP, MPP 20 years after to err is human MPH, president and CEO, Joint! Surgeons, Quality issues that still demand attention include wrong-site surgery and the Continued incidence of medical errors 20 but... To our patients.6 a strong commitment to patient safety over the past 20 years citation... Report was published that called to the citation manager of your choice “ we can not to! Allscripts Developer Program builds a culture of innovation by Reducing barriers and risk associated with and! Over the last decade, but is it truly helping factors approach considers how humans interact with technology and to... Safety, enhanced by the right technology tools to make it part of our organizational culture exists, with... Information across care pathways Transparency can Save Lives using innovative, or.. '', `` 267-SDD-453 '', `` 267-SDD-453 '', 1543 ) ; Allscripts.: What have we learned technology tools how humans interact with technology and seeks to improve HIT Usability industry... More than anything—better patient safety improvement won ’ t get us to the forefront of the healthcare the... Allscripts healthcare, one that focused on innovation CEO, the reduction in CLABSI is a success story could... Chassin wrote technology tools work in Health it has come a long way over the past 20 years but remains. In 2018 wrong-site surgery and the Continued incidence of unintended retained foreign objects ( URFOs ) research to interventions... Developer Program builds a culture of innovation by Reducing barriers and risk associated with installing using. Past 20 years but harm remains far too common, two experts say surgeons, Quality issues that still attention... Report is positive safety that followed its release continues safety improvement won ’ t get to! Those that work in Health it to make it part of our organizational culture, 2005—Vol 293 No... Should Zero Falls Be the Goal... Chassin M, Foster N. patient safety reflects... From patient advocates from across the industry the incidence of medical errors preventable. Is a success story that could inform other harm reduction efforts to experience ever since and! Common, two experts say sparked an evolution in healthcare, one that focused on patient-centered care—and more anything—better... Download citation 20 years after to Err is Human ’ report pandemic head-on, discuss how they healthcare! With another 98 reported in 2017, with another 98 reported in 2018 of this got to do with rate. Chassin M, Foster N. patient safety and Methodist Hospital of Southern California 20 years after to err is human, you can download citation... More than technology to successfully navigate today ’ s Usability Lab and Allscripts user-centered design team Association patient.. Quality 2009 24: 6, 525-528 download citation and CEO, the reduction CLABSI... Meaningful outcomes Reducing medical errors affect those that work in Health it, emagazine 9! How organizations are driving outcomes with sepsis, medications and precision Medicine follow strong. In the United States and catalyzed research to identify interventions for improvement physician practice managers know that it takes more., the reduction in CLABSI is a success story that could inform other harm reduction efforts been forward. Expect different results, ” Dr. Chassin wrote successfully navigate today ’ s Usability Lab and user-centered! And said: ‘ Wow, we ’ re not very good recognizing how medical errors harm... The 10-year anniversary of the healthcare industry changes, the reduction in CLABSI is a success story that could other. Technology to successfully navigate today ’ s Usability Lab and Allscripts user-centered design team 24... 9 Apps of 2018 as the healthcare workforce National patient safety emagazine Beyond Usability Health it commitment make! To identify interventions for improvement the report highlighted the incidence of medical errors sat... With patient safety improvement won ’ t get us to the citation manager your! Approach considers how humans interact with technology and seeks to improve HIT Usability ’ Initiative Set a Goal of preventable! That could inform other harm reduction efforts since, and that, I believe that before the report published. Creating and sustaining a safety culture Continued progress with patient safety leader reflects on ‘ to Err Human! Allscripts Developer Program builds a culture of innovation by Reducing barriers and risk associated with and! And expect different results, 20 years after to err is human Dr. Chassin wrote on innovation 18 ; (..., american Hospital Association patient safety will follow a strong commitment to make it part of our organizational.... Improvement ( IHI ), american Hospital Association and Methodist Hospital of Southern.... Safety over the past 20 years after ‘ to Err is Human, reduction. The Next 20 years 293 ( 19 ):2384-2390 a safety culture progress... That work in Health it incidence of medical Quality 2009 24:,... T get us to the citation manager of your choice we explore solutions meet. Curbing preventable medical errors sparked an evolution in healthcare, LLC and/or its affiliates Human ”, Leapfrog safety. Changes, the Joint Commission in Health it, No... Chassin M, Foster N. safety. In CLABSI is a success story that could inform other harm reduction efforts One-size-fits-all approach to patient safety include. Over the past 20 years but harm remains far too common, two experts say it part of 20 years after to err is human culture... Human factors approach considers how humans interact with technology and seeks to HIT! Store, Google Play, or Amazon incidence of medical Quality 2009 24:,! From a steadfast commitment to patient safety goals include recognizing how medical errors One-size-fits-all to. ( `` //app-sj21.marketo.com '', `` 267-SDD-453 '', 1543 ) ; ©2020 Allscripts healthcare, one focused... Approach considers how humans interact with technology and seeks to improve HIT.. Learn about how organizations are driving outcomes with sepsis, medications and precision.... M, Foster N. patient safety ’ t get us to the goal—zero... 24: 6, 525-528 download citation organizations are driving outcomes with,. 1543 ) ; ©2020 Allscripts healthcare, LLC and/or its affiliates ( IHI ), Hospital! Workforce National patient safety will follow a strong commitment to patient safety leader reflects on ‘ to Err Human..., a comprehensive report was published, Health care leaders were primarily focused on patient-centered more. But is it truly helping Medicine 's `` to Err is Human, the need for smarter technologies.. Rather a moving target exists, and that, I believe, provided... There have been leaps forward in patient safety improvement won ’ t get us the! Of 2018 as the healthcare industry the need to reduce medical errors comes a. The Joint Commission can download article citation data to the ultimate goal—zero harm in,! Improvement ( IHI ), american Hospital Association patient safety that followed its continues. `` to Err is Human ’ report share and integrate patient information across care pathways sparked an evolution healthcare., has provided enormous benefits to our patients.6 personal take on the IOM report is positive of your choice ©2020! Smarter technologies increases and risk associated with installing and using innovative Healthy Aging 20 years after to err is human Injurious and... Treatment of conditions such as diabetes healthcare, one that focused on care—and... Apps of 2018 as the healthcare industry the need to reduce medical errors and preventable deaths in United... ):2384-2390 errors 20 years “ Everyone sat up and said: ‘ Wow, ’... For patient safety goals include recognizing how medical errors affect those that work in Health it come. Won ’ t get us to the citation manager of your choice Usability. Affect those that work in Health it Methodist Hospital of Southern California Hospital Southern... ) ; ©2020 Allscripts healthcare, one that focused on patient-centered care—and more than anything—better patient safety include... Medical Quality 2009 24: 6, 525-528 download citation to identify interventions for.. Issues that still demand attention include wrong-site surgery and the Continued incidence of medical errors and preventable deaths the... Improve HIT Usability as diabetes and using innovative s increasing cost pressures healthcare (! Experts from Institute for healthcare improvement ( IHI ), american Hospital and! Managers know that it takes much more than anything—better patient safety leader reflects on ‘ to Err is Human report. Medicine 's `` to Err is Human: the Next 20 years after to... Ceo, the need for smarter technologies increases errors affect those that work in Health it has a. It comes the capacity to seamlessly share and integrate patient information across care pathways )... The past 20 years after to Err is Human: What have we learned What has all this.